基于CiteSpace的非稳态负荷相关研究热点及前沿的可视化分析

doi:10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2023.0341

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 背景非稳态负荷是衡量机体慢性应激的多系统生理指标，反映了慢性应激暴露对身体的累积生理负担，对慢性疾病的防治具有重要意义。近年来非稳态负荷相关研究逐渐增多，但国内相关研究发展较慢。回顾非稳态负荷相关研究文献，全面了解该领域发展趋势及热点，有助于促进我国非稳态负荷研究领域的创新发展。目的通过分析近年来发表的非稳态负荷的相关文献，了解该领域的研究热点和前沿，为以后研究提供参考。方法在Web of Science核心合集的科学引文索引扩展（SCIE）数据库中检索从建库至2022-12-01以非稳态负荷为主题的文献，应用Microsoft Excel 2019和CiteSpace软件对文献进行发文量、国家、作者、机构和关键词的可视化分析。结果共纳入509篇文献，年发文量呈缓慢增长趋势，美国是发文量（315篇）和中介中心性（0.65）均位居第一的国家。发文量排名前3位的作者是加拿大的JUSTER（23篇）、美国的SEEMAN（16篇）和美国的KARLAMANGLA（12篇）。发文量排名前3位的机构分别是位于美国的加利福尼亚大学洛杉矶分校（39篇）、加拿大的蒙特利尔大学（21篇）和美国的密歇根大学（20篇）。高频关键词包括非稳态负荷、应激、健康、社会经济地位、累积生物风险，关键词突现分析中突现程度最高的关键词是血压（突现强度为5.8）。结论非稳态负荷的研究正逐渐成为新的学术热点，研究热点主要聚焦于非稳态负荷的影响因素及其与健康结局的关联，干预研究极少。我国在该领域仍需进一步探索，未来研究可考虑扩大研究对象的范围，制定针对不同人群的非稳态负荷测量方法并形成规范以及开展相关干预性研究，促进人类健康。

关键词: 非稳态负荷, 应激，心理学, 慢性应激, 文献计量学, 可视化分析

Abstract:

Background

Allostatic load (AL) is a multi-systematic physiological indicator to measure chronic stress in the body, reflecting the cumulative physiological burden of chronic stress exposure on the body, which is of great significance for prevention and treatment of chronic diseases. In recent years, studies related to AL are gradually increasing, however, the development of domestic AL related studies is slow. Reviewing the literature related to AL and comprehensively understanding the development trends and hotspots in this field will be beneficial to prompt domestic innovative development of AL research in China.

Objective

To understand the research hotspots and frontiers in the field of AL and provide reference for future research by analyzing the relevant literature on AL published in recent years.

Methods

Science Citation Index Expanded of Web of Science Core Collection database was searched for literature on the topic of AL from inception to 2022-12-01. Microsoft Excel 2019 and CiteSpace software were applied to perform a visualization analysis of collected articles regarding the publication volume, countries, authors, institutions and keywords.

Results

A total of 509 articles were included, with a slowly increasing trend in annual publication volume. The United States ranked first in annual publication volume (315 articles) and betweenness centrality (0.65) . The top three authors in terms of publication volume were JUSTER of Canada (23 articles) , SEEMAN of the United States (16 articles) and KARLAMANGLA of the United States (12 articles) . The top three institutions in terms of publication volume were the University of California, Los Angeles (39 articles) , the University of Montreal in Canada (21 articles) and the University of Michigan in the United States (20 articles) , respectively. High-frequency keywords included AL, stress, health, socio-economic status, cumulative biological risk. Blood pressure was the keyword with the strongest citation bursts, the strength was 5.8.

Conclusion

The research on AL is gradually becoming a new academic hotspot, which mainly focuses on the influencing factors of AL and its relationship with health outcomes, with rare intervention studies. The domestic development in this field still needs to be further explored. Expanding the scope of research participants, formulating AL measurement methods for different populations and forming norms, as well as performing relevant intervention research should be considered in future studies to promote human health.

Key words: Allostatic load, Stress, psychological, Chronic stress, Bibliometric, Visualization

丁礼雪,李玉红,张玉东. 基于CiteSpace的非稳态负荷相关研究热点及前沿的可视化分析[J]. 中国全科医学, 2024, 27(08): 1008-1014. DOI: 10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2023.0341.
DING Lixue,LI Yuhong,ZHANG Yudong. Analysis of Hotspots and Frontiers of Allostatic Load Research: a Visualization Analysis Based on CiteSpace[J]. Chinese General Practice, 2024, 27(08): 1008-1014. DOI: 10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2023.0341.

图/表 10

参考文献 32

[1]	MCEWEN B S, STELLAR E. Stress and the individual. Mechanisms leading to disease[J]. Arch Intern Med，1993,153(18):2093-2101.
[2]	MCEWEN B S, SEEMAN T. Protective and damaging effects of mediators of stress. Elaborating and testing the concepts of allostasis and allostatic load[J]. Ann N Y Acad Sci，1999,896:30-47. DOI：10.1111/j.1749-6632.1999.tb08103.x.
[3]	JUSTER R P, MCEWEN B S, LUPIEN S J. Allostatic load biomarkers of chronic stress and impact on health and cognition[J]. Neurosci Biobehav Rev，2010,35(1):2-16. DOI：10.1016/j.neubiorev.2009.10.002.
[4]	DOAN S N. Allostatic load：developmental and conceptual considerations in a multi-system physiological indicator of chronic stress exposure[J]. Dev Psychobiol，2021,63(5):825-836. DOI：10.1002/dev.22107.
[5]	GUIDI J, LUCENTE M, SONINO N，et al. Allostatic load and its impact on health：a systematic review[J]. Psychother Psychosom，2021,90(1):11-27. DOI：10.1159/000510696.
[6]	OBENG-GYASI E, FERGUSON A C, STAMATAKIS K A，et al. Combined effect of lead exposure and allostatic load on cardiovascular disease mortality-a preliminary study[J]. Int J Environ Res Public Health，2021,18(13):6879. DOI：10.3390/ijerph18136879.
[7]	BECKLES G L, MCKEEVER BULLARD K, SAYDAH S，et al. Life course socioeconomic position，allostatic load，and incidence of type 2 diabetes among African American adults：the Jackson heart study，2000-04 to 2012[J]. Ethn Dis，2019,29(1):39-46. DOI：10.18865/ed.29.1.39.
[8]	MATHEW A, DOORENBOS A Z, LI H J，et al. Allostatic load in cancer：a systematic review and mini meta-analysis[J]. Biol Res Nurs，2021,23(3):341-361. DOI：10.1177/1099800420969898.
[9]	SABBAH W, GOMAA N, GIREESH A. Stress，allostatic load，and periodontal diseases[J]. Periodontol 2000,2018,78(1):154-161. DOI：10.1111/prd.12238.
[10]	SYNNESTVEDT M B, CHEN C M, HOLMES J H. CiteSpace Ⅱ：visualization and knowledge discovery in bibliographic databases[J]. AMIA Annu Symp Proc，2005,2005:724-728.
[11]	CHEN C M, IBEKWE-SANJUAN F, HOU J H. The structure and dynamics of cocitation clusters：a multiple-perspective cocitation analysis[J]. J Am Soc Inf Sci，2010,61(7):1386-1409. DOI：10.1002/asi.21309.
[12]	LUNYERA J, STANIFER J W, DAVENPORT C A，et al. Life course socioeconomic status，allostatic load，and kidney health in black Americans[J]. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol，2020,15(3):341-348. DOI：10.2215/CJN.08430719.
[13]	UPCHURCH D M, STEIN J, GREENDALE G A，et al. A longitudinal investigation of race，socioeconomic status，and psychosocial mediators of allostatic load in midlife women：findings from the study of women's health across the nation[J]. Psychosom Med，2015,77(4):402-412. DOI：10.1097/PSY.0000000000000175.
[14]	LONGPRÉ-POIRIER C, DOUGOUD J, JACMIN-PARK S，et al. Sex and gender and allostatic mechanisms of cardiovascular risk and disease[J]. Can J Cardiol，2022,38(12):1812-1827. DOI：10.1016/j.cjca.2022.09.011.
[15]	TAVARES C D, BELL C N, ZARE H，et al. Allostatic load，income，and race among black and white men in the United States[J]. Am J Mens Health，2022,16(2):15579883221092290. DOI：10.1177/15579883221092290.
[16]	FINLAY S, ROTH C, ZIMSEN T，et al. Adverse childhood experiences and allostatic load：a systematic review[J]. Neurosci Biobehav Rev，2022,136:104605. DOI：10.1016/j.neubiorev.2022.104605.
[17]	ZHANG D, LI T T, XIE Y，et al. Interaction between physical activity and outdoor time on allostatic load in Chinese college students[J]. BMC Public Health，2022,22(1):187. DOI：10.1186/s12889-022-12518-0.
[18]	FERNANDEZ C A, LOUCKS E B, ARHEART K L，et al. Evaluating the effects of coping style on allostatic load，by sex：the Jackson heart study，2000-2004[J]. Prev Chronic Dis，2015,12:E165. DOI：10.5888/pcd12.150166.
[19]	DEUSTER P A, KIM-DORNER S J, REMALEY A T，et al. Allostatic load and health status of African Americans and whites[J]. Am J Health Behav，2011,35(6):641-653. DOI：10.5993/ajhb.35.6.1.
[20]	VACCARINO S R, RAJJI T K, GILDENGERS A G，et al. Allostatic load but not medical burden predicts memory performance in late-life bipolar disorder[J]. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry，2018,33(3):546-552. DOI：10.1002/gps.4829.
[21]	BARRETT E S, VITEK W, MBOWE O，et al. Allostatic load，a measure of chronic physiological stress，is associated with pregnancy outcomes，but not fertility，among women with unexplained infertility[J]. Hum Reprod，2018,33(9):1757-1766. DOI：10.1093/humrep/dey261.
[22]	SIBILLE K T, MCBETH J, SMITH D，et al. Allostatic load and pain severity in older adults：results from the English Longitudinal Study of Ageing[J]. Exp Gerontol，2017,88:51-58. DOI：10.1016/j.exger.2016.12.013.
[23]	AKINYEMIJU T, WILSON L E, DEVEAUX A，et al. Association of allostatic load with all-cause andCancer mortality by race and body mass index in theREGARDS cohort[J]. Cancers，2020,12(6):1695. DOI：10.3390/cancers12061695.
[24]	SEEMAN T E, MCEWEN B S, ROWE J W，et al. Allostatic load as a marker of cumulative biological risk：MacArthur studies of successful aging[J]. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A，2001,98(8):4770-4775. DOI：10.1073/pnas.081072698.
[25]	BEESE S, POSTMA J, GRAVES J M. Allostatic load measurement：a systematic review of reviews，database inventory，and considerations for neighborhood research[J]. Int J Environ Res Public Health，2022,19(24):17006. DOI：10.3390/ijerph192417006.
[26]	ACCORTT E E, MIROCHA J, DUNKEL SCHETTER C，et al. Adverse perinatal outcomes and postpartum multi-systemic dysregulation：adding vitamin D deficiency to the allostatic load index[J]. Matern Child Health J，2017,21(3):398-406. DOI：10.1007/s10995-016-2226-3.
[27]	MCLOUGHLIN S, KENNY R A, MCCRORY C. Does the choice of Allostatic Load scoring algorithm matter for predicting age-related health outcomes?[J]. Psychoneuroendocrinology，2020,120:104789. DOI：10.1016/j.psyneuen.2020.104789.
[28]	PARK L, GOMAA N, QUINONEZ C. Racial/ethnic inequality in the association of allostatic load and dental caries in children[J]. J Public Health Dent，2022,82(2):239-246. DOI：10.1111/jphd.12470.
[29]	ERSIG A L, BROWN R L, MALECKI K. Clinical measures of allostatic load in children and adolescents with food allergy，depression，or anxiety[J]. J Pediatr Nurs，2021,61:346-354. DOI：10.1016/j.pedn.2021.08.025.
[30]	XU Y X, HUANG Y, ZHOU Y，et al. Association between bedroom light exposure at night and allostatic load among Chinese young adults[J]. Environ Pollut，2022,308:119671. DOI：10.1016/j.envpol.2022.119671.
[31]	KONLAN K D, ASAMPONG E, DAKO-GYEKE P，et al. Burnout and allostatic load among health workers engaged in human resourced-constrained hospitals in Accra，Ghana[J]. BMC Health Serv Res，2022,22(1):1163. DOI：10.1186/s12913-022-08539-5.
[32]	O'CONNOR D B, THAYER J F, VEDHARA K. Stress and health：a review of psychobiological processes[J]. Annu Rev Psychol，2021,72:663-688. DOI：10.1146/annurev-psych-062520-122331.

序号	作者	发文量（篇）	总被引次数（次）	篇均被引次数（次）	h-index
1	JUSTER	23	3 624	30.45	31
2	SEEMAN	16	11 925	44.33	68
3	KARLAMANGLA	12	8 730	46.19	59
4	LUPIEN	7	13 379	62.81	60
5	GRUENEWALD	7	3 143	45.55	36
6	DICH	6	303	12.63	13
7	SARNYAI	6	1 830	34.53	6
8	DELPIERRE	5	3 609	24.06	32
9	MERKIN	5	2 169	30.99	25
10	CHIAPPELLI	5	1 230	13.98	23

序号	作者	发文量（篇）	总被引次数（次）	篇均被引次数（次）	h-index
1	JUSTER	23	3 624	30.45	31
2	SEEMAN	16	11 925	44.33	68
3	KARLAMANGLA	12	8 730	46.19	59
4	LUPIEN	7	13 379	62.81	60
5	GRUENEWALD	7	3 143	45.55	36
6	DICH	6	303	12.63	13
7	SARNYAI	6	1 830	34.53	6
8	DELPIERRE	5	3 609	24.06	32
9	MERKIN	5	2 169	30.99	25
10	CHIAPPELLI	5	1 230	13.98	23

序号	地区	发文量（篇）	所占比例（%）	中心性
1	USA（美国）	315	53.94	0.65
2	Canada（加拿大）	61	10.45	0.08
3	England（英国）	56	9.59	0.14
4	Germany（德国）	25	4.28	0.05
5	Italy（意大利）	25	4.28	0.1
6	China（中国）	24	4.11	0.01
7	Australia（澳大利亚）	22	3.77	0.03
8	Denmark（丹麦）	20	3.42	0
9	Sweden（瑞典）	19	3.25	0.02
10	Scotland（苏格兰）	17	2.91	0.01

序号	地区	发文量（篇）	所占比例（%）	中心性
1	USA（美国）	315	53.94	0.65
2	Canada（加拿大）	61	10.45	0.08
3	England（英国）	56	9.59	0.14
4	Germany（德国）	25	4.28	0.05
5	Italy（意大利）	25	4.28	0.1
6	China（中国）	24	4.11	0.01
7	Australia（澳大利亚）	22	3.77	0.03
8	Denmark（丹麦）	20	3.42	0
9	Sweden（瑞典）	19	3.25	0.02
10	Scotland（苏格兰）	17	2.91	0.01

序号	关键词	频次（次）	中心性
1	Allostatic load（非稳态负荷）	346	0.02
2	Stress（应激）	173	0.03
3	Health（健康）	154	0.06
4	Macarthur（麦克阿瑟）	113	0.05
5	Socioeconomic status（社会经济地位）	105	0.01
6	Risk（风险）	95	0.06
7	Cumulative biological risk（累积生物风险）	88	0.11
8	Mortality（死亡率）	72	0.03
9	Disease（疾病）	72	0.14
10	Physiological dysregulation（生理失调）	59	0.01
11	Chronic stress（慢性应激）	58	0.20
12	Mental health（心理健康）	45	0.10
13	Association（联系）	44	0.23
14	Metabolic syndrome（代谢综合征）	43	0.07
15	United states（美国）	39	0.04
16	Cardiovascular disease（心血管疾病）	39	0.12
17	Adaptation（适应）	35	0.15
18	African American（非裔美国人）	35	0.08
19	Age（老龄化）	34	0.13
20	Blood pressure（血压）	33	0.08
21	Adult（成人）	32	0.00