中国全科医学 ›› 2024, Vol. 27 ›› Issue (03): 364-374.DOI: 10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2023.0414

• 论著·医学循证 • 上一篇    下一篇

中国卒中后疲劳患病率及发展趋势的Meta分析

薛超1, 李娟2,*(), 方茜2, 余洁1, 郝明青1   

  1. 1550002 贵州省贵阳市,贵州中医药大学护理学院
    2550002 贵州省贵阳市,贵州省人民医院护理部
  • 收稿日期:2023-06-07 修回日期:2023-08-15 出版日期:2024-01-20 发布日期:2023-10-23
  • 通讯作者: 李娟

  • 作者贡献:薛超负责文章构思与设计、论文撰写与修订;薛超、余洁、郝明青负责文献检索、数据提取、质量评价及数据分析;李娟、方茜负责文章审校及质量控制,并对文章整体负责。
  • 基金资助:
    国家自然科学基金资助项目(72364005); 贵州省中医药管理局中医药、民族医药科学技术课题研究资助(QZYY-2023-115); 贵州省卫生健康委员会科学技术基金(gzwkj2021-476)

Prevalence and Trends for Post-stroke Fatigue in China: a Meta-analysis

XUE Chao1, LI Juan2,*(), FANG Qian2, YU Jie1, HAO Mingqing1   

  1. 1School of Nursing, Guizhou University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Guiyang 550002, China
    2Department of Nursing, Guizhou Provincial People's Hospital, Guiyang 550002, China
  • Received:2023-06-07 Revised:2023-08-15 Published:2024-01-20 Online:2023-10-23
  • Contact: LI Juan

摘要: 背景 卒中后疲劳(PSF)严重影响患者预后恢复,也是卒中复发和卒中后死亡的独立危险因素。了解PSF的流行病学现状对于推进我国卒中防治工作具有重要意义。 目的 系统评价中国PSF患病现状及发展趋势,为我国相关部门制订有针对性地脑卒中防治策略提供参考依据。 方法 计算机检索PubMed、Web of Science、Embase、中国知网(CNKI)、万方数据知识服务平台(Wanfang Data)、维普网(VIP)和中国生物医学文献数据库(CBM),搜集有关中国PSF患病率的横断面研究,检索时限均从建库至2023-05-20。由2名研究者独立筛选文献,提取资料并评价纳入研究的偏倚风险,采用Stata 16.0软件进行Meta分析。 结果 共纳入57个横断面研究,涉及中国19个省/自治区/直辖市及特别行政区,总样本量为13 621例,其中PSF者5 764例。Meta分析结果显示,我国PSF患病率为43.5%(95%CI=40.0%~47.0%)。亚组分析结果显示,按性别分组,男性患病率为38.4%(95%CI=34.3%~42.5%),女性为45.2%(95%CI=40.7%~49.7%);按年龄分组,<60岁为40.0%(95%CI=32.3%~48.0%),60~75岁为67.9%(95%CI=54.2%~80.1%),>75岁为71.9%(95%CI=48.9%~90.5%);按地理分区分组,华北地区为40.0%(95%CI=35.0%~45.2%),东北地区为41.0%(95%CI=29.5%~53.0%),华东地区为49.5%(95%CI=43.1%~55.8%),华中地区为40.3%(95%CI=34.9%~45.8%),华南地区为40.0%(95%CI=28.4%~52.2%),西南地区为59.3%(95%CI=54.0%~65.0%),西北地区为46.2%(95%CI=38.3%~54.2%);按卒中性质分组,出血性脑卒中为56.3%(95%CI=42.8%~69.4%),缺血性脑卒中为40.0%(95%CI=36.7%~43.4%);按卒中分期分组,急性期为41.4%(95%CI=37.0%~45.8%),恢复期为46.4%(95%CI=40.8%~52.1%);按受教育程度分组,小学及以下为56.0%(95%CI=43.7%~67.9%),初中为46.7%(95%CI=39.6%~53.8%),高中为46.8%(95%CI=40.3%~53.4%),大专及以上为43.6%(95%CI=35.7%~51.6%);按婚姻状况分组,有配偶者为45.8%(95%CI=40.8%~50.9%),无配偶者为53.6%(95%CI=47.4%~59.8%);按工作状况分组,在职者为45.0%(95%CI=33.2%~57.0%),无业或退休者为53.8%(95%CI=40.1%~67.2%);按评估工具分组,应用疲劳严重程度量表(FSS)为41.8%(95%CI=38.3%~45.3%),应用个人疲劳强度问卷(CIS)为65.8%(95%CI=57.1%~74.0%),应用中文版卒中神经疲劳指数(NFI-stroke)为50.5%(95%CI=44.6%~56.5%),应用中文版疲劳评估量表(C-FAS)为52.7%(95%CI=43.1%~62.1%),应用精神疲劳自评量表(MFS)为48.9%(95%CI=43.6%~54.2%)。此外,从年龄分布来看,我国PSF患病率随年龄增长而逐渐增加(χ2趋势=87.081,r=0.209,P<0.01);从文化背景来看,我国PSF患病率与受教育程度的无相关趋势(χ2趋势=0.333,P=0.564);从空间分布来看,全国7个地区PSF患病率(40.0%~59.3%)间差异有统计学意义(χ2=122.615,P<0.01),19个省级行政区PSF患病率(23.3%~74.2%)间差异有统计学意义(χ2=504.294,P<0.01);从发表时间来看,2013年1月—2023年5月我国PSF患病率(32.4%~53.9%)有增长趋势(χ2趋势=48.011,P<0.01)。 结论 中国PSF总体患病率较高,不同地区、省份之间存在明显差异,其中西南地区和贵州省最高,而华北地区、华南地区及天津市最低。此外,女性、高龄、无配偶、受教育程度低、无业或退休、卒中恢复期、脑出血等群体PSF患病率偏高。

关键词: 脑卒中, 疲劳, 患病率, 发展趋势, Meta分析, 系统评价, 中国

Abstract:

Background

Post-stroke fatigue (PSF) has a significant impact on patients' prognostic recovery and is an independent risk factor for stroke recurrence and post-stroke death. Therefore, understanding the current epidemiological status of PSF is of great significant in promoting stroke prevention and treatment in China.

Objective

To systematically evaluate the current situation and development trend of PSF in China, in order to provide a reference basis for the relevant departments to formulate targeted stroke prevention and treatment strategies.

Methods

PubMed, Web of Science, Embase, CNKI, Wanfang Data, VIP, and CBM were searched by computer to collect cross-sectional studies on the prevalence of PSF in China from inception to 2023-05-20. Meta-analysis was performed using Stata 16.0 software after 2 investigators independently screened the literature, extracted information and evaluated the risk of bias of the included studies.

Results

A total of 57 cross-sectional studies involving 19 provinces/autonomous regions/municipalities directly under the central government and special administrative regions of China, with a total sample size of 13 621 individuals, including 5 764 individuals with PSF. Meta-analysis showed that the prevalence of PSF in China was 43.5% (95%CI=40.0%-47.0%). The results of subgroup analysis showed that the prevalence was 38.4% (95%CI=34.3%-42.5%) for men and 45.2% (95%CI=40.7%-49.7%) for women by gender grouping; the prevalence was 40.0% (95%CI=32.3%-48.0%) for those under 60 years of age, 67.9% (95%CI=54.2%-80.1%) for those aged 60-75 years by age grouping and 71.9% (95%CI=48.9%-90.5%) for those aged 75 years and above; the prevalence was 40.0% (95%CI=35.0%-45.2%) in North China, 41.0% (95%CI=29.5%-53.0%) in Northeast China, 49.5% (95%CI=43.1%-55.8%) in East China, 40.3% (95%CI=34.9%-45.8%) in Central China, 40.0% (95%CI=28.4%-52.2%) in South China, 59.3% (95%CI=54.0%-65.0%) in Southwest China, and 46.2% (95%CI=38.3%-54.2%) in Northwest China by regional grouping; the prevalence was 56.3% (95%CI=42.8%-69.4%) for hemorrhagic stroke and 40.0% (95%CI=36.7%-43.4%) for ischemic stroke by stroke nature grouping; the prevalence was 41.4% (95%CI=37.0%-45.8%) for acute phase and 46.4% (95%CI=40.8%-52.1%) for recovery phase by stroke duration grouping; the prevalence was 56.0% (95%CI=43.7%-67.9%) for elementary school and below, 46.7% (95%CI=39.6%-53.8%) for junior high school, 46.8% (95%CI=40.3%-53.4%) for senior high school, and 43.6% (95%CI=35.7%-51.6%) for college and above by education level grouping; the prevalence was 45.8% (95%CI=40.8%-50.9%) for those with a spouse and 53.6% (95%CI=47.4%-59.8%) for those without a spouse by marital status; the prevalence was 45.0% (95%CI=33.2%-57.0%) for those who were employed and 53.8% (95%CI=40.1%-67.2%) for those who were unemployed or retired by work status grouping; the prevalence was 41.8% (95%CI=38.3%-45.3%) for those who applied the Fatigue Severity Scale (FSS), 65.8% (95%CI=57.1%-74.0%) for those who applied the Check List Individual Strength (CIS), 50.5% (95%CI=44.6%-56.5%) for those who applied the Chinese version of the Neurological Fatigue Index for Stroke (NFI-stroke), 52.7% (95%CI=43.1%-62.1%) for those who applied the Chinese version of the Fatigue Assessment Scale (C-FAS), and 48.9% (95%CI=43.6%-54.2%) for those who applied the Mental Fatigue Self-Rating Scale (MFS). Additionally, in terms of age distribution, the prevalence of PSF in China increased gradually with age (χ2trend=87.081, r=0.209, P<0.01) ; in terms of cultural background, the trend of correlation between the prevalence of PSF in China and education level was not statistically significant (χ2trend=0.333, P=0.564) ; and in terms of spatial distribution, the prevalence of PSF (40.0%-59.3%) varied significantly among the seven regions of the country (χ2=122.615, P<0.01), and the prevalence of PSF (23.3%-74.2%) also varied significantly among 19 provincial-level administrative regions in China (χ2=504.294, P<0.01) ; from the perspective of the publication time, the prevalence of PSF in China fluctuated in 32.4% to 53.9% from January 2013 to May 2023 (χ2trend=48.011, P<0.01) .

Conclusion

The results of this study have shown a high overall prevalence of PSF in China, with significant differences among regions and provinces. The highest prevalence was found in Southwest China and Guizhou Province, whereas the lowest prevalence was observed in North China, South China, and Tianjin City. Additionally, PSF was found to be more prevalent among certain groups, including females, advanced age, no spouse, low education level, unemployed or retired work status, recovery phase of stroke, and hemorrhagic stroke.

Key words: Stroke, Fatigue, Prevalence, Development trends, Meta-analysis, Systematic review, China