
Chinese General Practice ›› 2023, Vol. 26 ›› Issue (08): 1008-1014.DOI: 10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2022.0588
Special Issue: 脑健康最新研究合辑
• Evidence-based Medicine • Previous Articles Next Articles
Received:2022-04-12
Revised:2022-08-26
Published:2023-03-15
Online:2022-10-27
Contact:
LIU Fangli
通讯作者:
刘芳丽
作者简介:基金资助:
Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX
URL: https://www.chinagp.net/EN/10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2022.0588
| 步骤 | 检索式 |
|---|---|
| #1 | stroke OR cerebrovascular stroke OR cerebral stroke OR acute stroke OR cerebrovascular accident OR brain vascular accident OR acute cerebrovascular accident |
| #2 | post stroke fatigue OR fatigue OR PSF |
| #3 | non-invasive brain stimulation OR transcranial direct current stimulation OR tDCS OR repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation OR rTMS |
| #4 | clinical randomized controlled trial OR randomized controlled study OR RCT |
| #5 | #1AND #2 AND #3 AND #4 |
Table 1 Strategy for searching RCTs in PubMed database
| 步骤 | 检索式 |
|---|---|
| #1 | stroke OR cerebrovascular stroke OR cerebral stroke OR acute stroke OR cerebrovascular accident OR brain vascular accident OR acute cerebrovascular accident |
| #2 | post stroke fatigue OR fatigue OR PSF |
| #3 | non-invasive brain stimulation OR transcranial direct current stimulation OR tDCS OR repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation OR rTMS |
| #4 | clinical randomized controlled trial OR randomized controlled study OR RCT |
| #5 | #1AND #2 AND #3 AND #4 |
| 第一作者 | 发表时间(年) | 样本量 | 年龄(岁) | 卒中时间 | 干预措施 | 刺激部位 | 评估量表 | 干预时间 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E | C | E | C | E | C | E | C | |||||
| DONG[ | 2021 | 26 | 27 | 60.42±9.76 | 59.48±9.12 | 42.12±7.35 | 41.85±7.41 | tDCS(1.5 mA,20 min) | 假刺激 | L-DLPFC、右眼眶上缘 | FSS、FMA | 4周、8周,6次/周 |
| 李洁[ | 2022 | 40 | 40 | 61.33±9.65 | 59.24±8.35 | — | — | 头针治疗+rTMS | 头针治疗 | L-M1、R-M1 | FSS | 8周,6次/周 |
| DE DONCKER[ | 2021 | 20 | 10 | 56.9±13.17 | 59.8±11.66 | 4.19±5.43 | 4.83±6.47 | tDCS(2 mA,20 min) | 假刺激 | L-M1、R-M1 | FSS-7 | 5周,6次/周 |
| 郑双双[ | 2020 | 39 | 39 | 54.48±9.25 | 53.54±10.02 | 2.01±0.13 | 1.78±0.34 | rTMS+CBT | 常规护理 | L-M1、R-M1及DLPEC | FSS、FMA | 4周、8周,5次/周 |
| 孙瑞[ | 2019 | 45 | 45 | 51.5±12.4 | 50.7±13.1 | 2.9±1.5 | 3.1±2.0 | rTMS | 常规护理 | L-M1、R-M1及DLPEC | FSS、FMA | 4周、8周,5次/周 |
Table 2 Basic features of included RCTs
| 第一作者 | 发表时间(年) | 样本量 | 年龄(岁) | 卒中时间 | 干预措施 | 刺激部位 | 评估量表 | 干预时间 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E | C | E | C | E | C | E | C | |||||
| DONG[ | 2021 | 26 | 27 | 60.42±9.76 | 59.48±9.12 | 42.12±7.35 | 41.85±7.41 | tDCS(1.5 mA,20 min) | 假刺激 | L-DLPFC、右眼眶上缘 | FSS、FMA | 4周、8周,6次/周 |
| 李洁[ | 2022 | 40 | 40 | 61.33±9.65 | 59.24±8.35 | — | — | 头针治疗+rTMS | 头针治疗 | L-M1、R-M1 | FSS | 8周,6次/周 |
| DE DONCKER[ | 2021 | 20 | 10 | 56.9±13.17 | 59.8±11.66 | 4.19±5.43 | 4.83±6.47 | tDCS(2 mA,20 min) | 假刺激 | L-M1、R-M1 | FSS-7 | 5周,6次/周 |
| 郑双双[ | 2020 | 39 | 39 | 54.48±9.25 | 53.54±10.02 | 2.01±0.13 | 1.78±0.34 | rTMS+CBT | 常规护理 | L-M1、R-M1及DLPEC | FSS、FMA | 4周、8周,5次/周 |
| 孙瑞[ | 2019 | 45 | 45 | 51.5±12.4 | 50.7±13.1 | 2.9±1.5 | 3.1±2.0 | rTMS | 常规护理 | L-M1、R-M1及DLPEC | FSS、FMA | 4周、8周,5次/周 |
| 干预时间 | 类型 | 纳入研究数量(篇) | 异质性检验结果 | 效应模型 | Meta分析结果 | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P值 | I2(%) | SMD(95%CI) | P值 | ||||
| 4周 | rTMS | 2[ | 0.04 | 76 | 随机效应模型 | -0.87(-1.19,-0.55) | <0.001 |
| tDCS | 1[ | — | — | — | -5.10(-8.71,-1.49) | — | |
| 8周 | rTMS | 3[ | <0.01 | 99 | 随机效应模型 | -1.02(-1.10,-0.94) | <0.001 |
| tDCS | 1[ | — | — | — | -6.74(-10.16,-3.32) | — | |
Table 3 Subgroup analysis of the effects of intervention time on Fatigue Severity Scale scores
| 干预时间 | 类型 | 纳入研究数量(篇) | 异质性检验结果 | 效应模型 | Meta分析结果 | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P值 | I2(%) | SMD(95%CI) | P值 | ||||
| 4周 | rTMS | 2[ | 0.04 | 76 | 随机效应模型 | -0.87(-1.19,-0.55) | <0.001 |
| tDCS | 1[ | — | — | — | -5.10(-8.71,-1.49) | — | |
| 8周 | rTMS | 3[ | <0.01 | 99 | 随机效应模型 | -1.02(-1.10,-0.94) | <0.001 |
| tDCS | 1[ | — | — | — | -6.74(-10.16,-3.32) | — | |
| 结局指标 | 干预方式 | 纳入研究数量(篇) | 例数(例) | 研究类型 | 降低证据的质量因素 | 总证据质量(GRADE) | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 偏倚风险 | 间接性 | 不一致性 | 不精确性 | 发表偏倚 | ||||||
| 4周FSS | rTMS | 2[ | 168 | RCT | 降1级a | 不降级 | 降1级b | 不降级 | 不降级 | 低 |
| tDCS | 1[ | 53 | RCT | 降1级a | 不降级 | 不降级 | 不降级 | 降1级c | 低 | |
| 8周FSS | rTMS | 3[ | 248 | RCT | 降1级a | 不降级 | 降1级b | 不降级 | 不降级 | 低 |
| tDCS | 1[ | 54 | RCT | 降1级a | 不降级 | 不降级 | 降1级d | 不降级 | 低 | |
| FMA | rTMS | 2[ | 168 | RCT | 降1级a | 不降级 | 降1级b | 不降级 | 不降级 | 低 |
| tDCS | 1[ | 53 | RCT | 降1级a | 不降级 | 不降级 | 不降级 | 降1级c | 低 | |
Table 4 GRADE summary table of the quality of the evidence for outcome measures
| 结局指标 | 干预方式 | 纳入研究数量(篇) | 例数(例) | 研究类型 | 降低证据的质量因素 | 总证据质量(GRADE) | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 偏倚风险 | 间接性 | 不一致性 | 不精确性 | 发表偏倚 | ||||||
| 4周FSS | rTMS | 2[ | 168 | RCT | 降1级a | 不降级 | 降1级b | 不降级 | 不降级 | 低 |
| tDCS | 1[ | 53 | RCT | 降1级a | 不降级 | 不降级 | 不降级 | 降1级c | 低 | |
| 8周FSS | rTMS | 3[ | 248 | RCT | 降1级a | 不降级 | 降1级b | 不降级 | 不降级 | 低 |
| tDCS | 1[ | 54 | RCT | 降1级a | 不降级 | 不降级 | 降1级d | 不降级 | 低 | |
| FMA | rTMS | 2[ | 168 | RCT | 降1级a | 不降级 | 降1级b | 不降级 | 不降级 | 低 |
| tDCS | 1[ | 53 | RCT | 降1级a | 不降级 | 不降级 | 不降级 | 降1级c | 低 | |
| [1] |
|
| [2] |
|
| [3] |
|
| [4] |
|
| [5] |
|
| [6] |
王新德.各类脑血管疾病诊断要点[J]. 中华神经科杂志,1996,29(6):60-61.
|
| [7] |
谷鸿秋,王杨,李卫. Cochrane偏倚风险评估工具在随机对照研究Meta分析中的应用[J]. 中国循环杂志,2014,29(2):147-148. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1000-3614.2014.02.017.
|
| [8] |
曾宪涛,冷卫东,李胜,等. 如何正确理解及使用GRADE系统[J]. 中国循证医学杂志,2011,11(9):985-990.
|
| [9] |
|
| [10] |
李洁,周芳,郑洋,等. 头针配合重复经颅磁刺激治疗脑卒中后疲劳的疗效观察[J]. 神经损伤与功能重建,2022,17(3):174-176. DOI:10.16780/j.cnki.sjssgncj.20200319.
|
| [11] |
|
| [12] |
郑双双,黎普刚,陈洁,等. 重复经颅磁刺激联合认知行为疗法对卒中后疲劳患者疲劳程度的影响[J]. 中华物理医学与康复杂志,2020,42(6):511-514. DOI:10.3760/cma.j.issn.0254-1424.2020.06.006.
|
| [13] |
孙瑞,李洁,李祖虹,等. 经颅磁刺激联合运动疗法对脑卒中后疲劳患者疲劳程度及炎性细胞因子的影响[J]. 中华物理医学与康复杂志,2019(1):23-27.
|
| [14] |
|
| [15] |
|
| [16] |
|
| [17] |
|
| [18] |
|
| [19] |
|
| [20] |
|
| [21] |
|
| [22] |
|
| [23] |
|
| [24] |
|
| [25] |
|
| [26] |
|
| [27] |
|
| [28] |
|
| [29] |
|
| [30] |
|
| [31] |
|
| [32] |
|
| [33] |
|
| [34] |
|
| [35] |
|
| [1] | YANG Xiaofeng, LI Xianwen, WU Yanfeng, ZHANG Qian, CHEN Juan, ZHAO Fengjiao. Association of Serum Vascular Endothelial Cadherin Levels with the Risk of Post-stroke Cognitive Impairment in Patients with Acute Ischemic Stroke [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2026, 29(20): 2867-2873. |
| [2] | LIU Ying, LIU Shiwei, ZHANG Chi, SHEN Ji, ZHANG Yushan, ZHANG Jie, SANG Yingchen, WANG Youjiao, WANG Lei, ZHOU Houguang, SHI Hong. Prevalence and Associated Factors of Subjective Cognitive Decline among Older Stroke Patients in China [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2026, 29(20): 2829-2835. |
| [3] | LI Yutong, ZHAO Danting, JIANG Feng, WANG Yanna, LIU Yizong, LIANG Wenjuan, LU Jiahai. Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of the Efficacy and Safety of mRNA and Recombinant Protein Subunit Vaccines Against Respiratory Syncytial Virus [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2026, 29(19): 2744-2752. |
| [4] | ZHANG Wenbo, WANG Junlong, ZHANG Yuping, JIANG Shuai, WANG Huaqi. The Risk of Pre-COPD Populations Progressing to COPD under Different Criteria: a Meta-analysis [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2026, 29(19): 2735-2743. |
| [5] | WU Ruining, ZHOU Ming, ZHANG Gongzi, LI Jun, XIE Suhang, LIU Yangxiaoxue, ZHANG Jiali, LIU Maomao, HUANG Liping. Study on Fixed and Mobile Exoskeleton Robots in Improving Lower Limb Function and Quality of Life in Stroke Patients: a Randomized Controlled Trial [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2026, 29(17): 2326-2333. |
| [6] | JI Ying, GUO Chuan, ZHU Shizhe, JI Panpan, WANG Tong, KAN Chaojie, WANG Qinglei. Effects of Intermittent Theta Burst Stimulation of the Cerebellum on Different Balance Abilities in Patients with Supratentorial Stroke: a Randomized Controlled Trial [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2026, 29(15): 2022-2028. |
| [7] | HAN Yue, BIAN Zhe, GU Haochen, WANG Dali, PENG Yanbo. Impact of Cumulative Defined Daily Dose of Statins on Recurrence Risk in Ischemic Stroke Patients [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2026, 29(14): 1821-1826. |
| [8] | ZHAN Li, HENG Zhaoyang, HE Liangyu, ZHAO Jie, CHEN Jie, XING Jinshan. Efficacy and Safety of CAR-T Therapy Targeting the B Cell Maturation Antigen on Relapsed/Refractory Multiple Myeloma in Chinese People: a Meta-analysis [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2026, 29(14): 1921-1930. |
| [9] | TIAN Anni, YANG Jing, SUN Jing, WANG Shichun. Effect of Robot-assisted Training on the Recovery of Hand Motor Function in Patients with Different Stages of Stroke: a Meta-analysis [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2026, 29(14): 1911-1920. |
| [10] | DUAN Ruolan, QIU Jiamei, YANG Changyuan, LI Qin, MO Haoyu, PI Minhui, YANG Zhenhua, XIA Ai, ZHANG La, LIU Xusheng, LU Fuhua, HOU Haijing, SU Guobin. Assessment of Fatigue in Patients with Chronic Kidney Disease: the Choice of Patient-reported Outcome Measures Scales [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2026, 29(13): 1784-1792. |
| [11] | LIU Yang, LIANG Fang, WU Ling, LI Wenlei, LI Pengfei. Diagnostic Value of Non-conventional Lipids and the Triglyceride-glucose Index in First-onset Acute Ischemic Stroke [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2026, 29(11): 1422-1429. |
| [12] | CAI Dongping, REN Wen, REN Jingjing. Features of Fatigue Patients from the General Practice Department of a General Hospital [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2026, 29(10): 1334-1339. |
| [13] | WANG Fei, HAN Weiyu, SUN Tao. Moxibustion Combined with Three-step Therapy in the Treatment of Cancer Pain: a Network Meta-analysis [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2026, 29(09): 1203-1211. |
| [14] | CAO Lei, LIU Xuechun, JIANG Wei, CHEN Yan, YAN Sunhong, DU Jing. Study on the Prediction of Muscle Attenuation in Patients with Acute Ischemic Stroke by the Cross-sectional Area and Thickness of the Temporalis Muscle [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2026, 29(08): 997-1007. |
| [15] | WANG Xiaonan, RUAN Xiaonan, LIU Yang, WU Kang, QIU Hua, LIU Qingping, SONG Jiahui, GAO Jiaojiao, ZHOU Yi, LIU Xiaolin. Correlation between Anthropometric Indices and the Risk of Stroke: a Nested Case-control Study [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2026, 29(08): 1020-1028. |
| Viewed | ||||||
|
Full text |
|
|||||
|
Abstract |
|
|||||