Chinese General Practice ›› 2023, Vol. 26 ›› Issue (30): 3809-3814.DOI: 10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2022.0871

• Original Research • Previous Articles     Next Articles

Cost-effectiveness Analysis of GnRH Antagonist Protocol and Short-acting GnRH Agonist Long Protocol in Fresh Embryo Transfer Based on Propensity Score Matching

  

  1. 1. Reproductive Medicine and Genetics Center, the People's Hospital of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, Nanning 530021, China
    2. Department of General Medicine, Guangxi Medical University, Nanning 530021, China
  • Received:2022-12-18 Revised:2023-03-15 Published:2023-10-20 Online:2023-04-21
  • Contact: ZUO Yanli

基于倾向性评分匹配法探究拮抗剂方案与短效长方案在鲜胚移植中应用的成本-效果分析

  

  1. 1.530021 广西壮族自治区南宁市,广西壮族自治区人民医院生殖医学与遗传中心
    2.530021 广西壮族自治区南宁市,广西医科大学全科医学院
  • 通讯作者: 左延莉
  • 作者简介:
    作者贡献:黄泰帅进行文章的构思,研究的设计与实施,数据收集和统计分析,论文撰写;池艳进行论文的修订;何萍、黄国兰进行数据收集,数据整理;左延莉对研究活动规划和执行进行监督和领导,负责文章的质量控制及审校,对文章整体负责;所有作者确认了论文的最终稿。
  • 基金资助:
    国家自然科学基金资助项目(71864006); 广西自然科学基金资助项目(2021GXNSFAA196075,2020GXNSFAA238019); 广西基层卫生健康发展研究中心(GXMUZX16); 广西高等教育本科教学改革工程项目(2022JGA155); 广西医药卫生自筹经费计划课题(Z20210746,Z20210984,Z20211296,GXZYZ20210115)

Abstract:

Background

In the field of assisted reproductive technology, medical cost of patients is increasingly considered as an important reference for making treatment protocols, while domestic health economics researches are rarely reported on the cost-effectiveness of gonadotropin-releasing hormone antagonist (GnRH-ant) protocol and short-acting GnRH agonist (GnRH-a) long protocol in fresh embryo transfer.

Objective

To analyse the cost-effectiveness of the clinical outcomes of GnRH-ant and GnRH-a protocols in fresh embryo transfer based on propensity score matching (PSM) .

Methods

A total of 1 971 patients treated with 2 117 cycles of in vitro fertilization/intracytoplasmic sperm injection and embryo transfer (IVF/ICSI-ET) at the Reproductive Medicine and Genetics Center of the People's Hospital of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region from 2016 to 2018 were selected and divided 422 patients with 432 cycles in the GnRH-ant group and 1 549 patients with 1 685 cycles in the GnRH-a group according to the protocols of controlled ovarian hyperstimulation (COH). Baseline data 〔including female age, type and duration of infertility, BMI, age at menarche, number of pregnancies, follicle stimulating hormone (FSH), basal estradiol (E2), basal luteinizing hormone (LH), basal progesterone, antral follicle count (AFC), etc.〕, therapeutic indicators 〔including COH protocols, gonadotropin (Gn) durarion, total Gn dosage, E2, LH, progesterone level and endometrial thickness on the trigger day, number of retrieved and mature oocytes, fertilization methods, number of transferable embryos, high-quality embryos and transferred embryos, etc.〕 and the clinical outcomes〔including unpregnancy, miscarriage, ectopic gestation, live birth (LB) 〕 were collected from the electronic medical record system and the 1∶1 PSM was performed using R 4.1.1 software with caliper value of 0.2. Cost-effectiveness analysis was performed on the two groups after PSM, sensitivity analysis was applied to verify the robustness of the study findings.

Results

There were significant differences in female age, BMI, basal FSH, LH, and AFC between the two groups before PSM (P<0.05). A total of 390 cycles were included in each group after PSM, and there was no significant difference in female age, BMI, basal FSH, LH, and AFC between the two groups after PSM (P>0.05). Therapeutic indicators including Gn duration, Gn dosage, E2 and endometrial thickness on the trigger day, number of retrieved and mature oocytes were lower in the GnRH-ant group than GnRH-a group, while LH level on the trigger day was higher in the GnRH-ant than the GnRH-a group (P<0.05) after PSM. Clinical outcomes including clinical pregnancy rate (43.08% vs. 54.62%, P=0.001), implantation rate (29.15% vs. 37.01%, P=0.001), and LB rate (33.59% vs. 44.10%, P=0.003) were significantly lower in the GnRH-ant group than GnRH-a group after PSM. The cost of ovulation induction drug per cycle and total cost per cycle were lower in the GnRH-ant group than the GnRH-a group after PSM (P<0.05). Using LB rate as the endpoint indicator, cost-effectiveness analysis showed that the cost per LB was 66 397.92 and 54 226.33 yuan in the GnRH-ant group and GnRH-a group, respectively. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio was 15 325.88 yuan, less than 1 time of per capita GDP in China in 2018 (64 644 yuan). The results of sensitivity analysis were consistent with the results of the basic analysis.

Conclusion

In fresh embryo transfer cycles, the clinical outcomes and economy performances of GnRH-a protocol are superior to GnRH-ant protocol.

Key words: Infertility, female, Embryo transfer, Ovulation induction, Clinical pregnancy, Live birth rate, Cost-effectiveness analysis, Propensity score matching

摘要:

背景

辅助生殖领域越来越多地把患者的助孕成本作为制订治疗方案时的重要依据,而国内关于拮抗剂方案与短效长方案在鲜胚移植中应用的卫生经济学研究相对少见。

目的

基于倾向性评分匹配法(PSM)对拮抗剂方案与短效长方案在鲜胚移植中应用的临床结局行成本-效果分析。

方法

选择2016—2018年在广西壮族自治区人民医院生殖医学与遗传中心接受体外受精/卵泡浆内单精子注射-胚胎移植(IVF/ICSI-ET)治疗的患者1 971例,共进行了2 117个周期的治疗,依据控制性超促排卵(COH)方案分为拮抗剂方案组422例患者、共432个周期,短效长方案组1 549例患者、共1 685个周期。在电子病历系统中收集患者的基线资料〔包含女方年龄、不孕类型、不孕年限、BMI、初潮年龄、妊娠次数、基础卵泡刺激素(FSH)、基础雌二醇(E2)、基础黄体生成素(LH)、基础孕酮、窦卵泡数(AFC)等〕、治疗指标〔包含COH方案、使用促性腺激素(Gn)天数、Gn总量、扳机日E2、扳机日LH、扳机日孕酮、扳机日子宫内膜厚度、获卵数、成熟卵母细胞数、受精方式、可移植胚胎数、优质胚胎数、移植胚胎数等〕及临床结局(包含未孕、流产、异位妊娠、活产)。应用R 4.1.1软件进行1∶1倾向性评分匹配,卡钳值设定为0.2。对匹配后的两组行成本-效果分析,应用敏感性分析验证研究结论的稳健性。

结果

PSM前两组女方年龄、BMI、基础FSH、基础LH、AFC比较,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05)。PSM后两组各390个周期,两组女方年龄、BMI、基础FSH、基础LH、AFC比较,差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。治疗指标:PSM后拮抗剂方案组的Gn天数、Gn总量、扳机日E2、扳机日子宫内膜厚度、获卵数、成熟卵母细胞数均小于短效长方案组,扳机日LH高于短效长方案组(P<0.05)。临床结局:PSM后拮抗剂方案组临床妊娠率(43.08%比54.62%,P=0.001)、种植率(29.15%比37.01%,P=0.001)、活产率(33.59%比44.10%,P=0.003)低于短效长方案组。PSM后拮抗剂方案组的每周期促排卵药物费用、每周期总费用低于短效长方案组(P<0.05)。以活产率作为本研究的终点指标,成本-效果分析表明,拮抗剂方案组每获得1例活产的成本为66 397.92元,短效长方案组为54 226.33元,增量成本-效果比为15 325.88元,小于1倍2018年中国人均GDP(64 644元)。敏感性分析结果与基础分析结果基本一致。

结论

在鲜胚移植周期使用短效长方案进行治疗的临床结局和经济性均优于拮抗剂方案。

关键词: 不育,女性, 胚胎移植, 排卵诱导, 临床妊娠, 活产率, 成本-效果分析, 倾向性评分匹配