中国全科医学

• •

全科门诊医患会话主题结构与差异研究

龚哲晰, 马力, 周家欣, 崔埔安, 林梦岚, 何仲   

  1. 1.北京协和医学院人文和社会科学学院 2.首都医科大学附属北京天坛医院全科医疗科 3.中国中医科学院西苑医院
  • 收稿日期:2024-11-07 修回日期:2024-12-17 接受日期:2024-12-25
  • 通讯作者: 何仲
  • 基金资助:
    教育部新文科研究与改革实践项目《新医科与新文科融合——中国医学人文学科及专业现状与繁荣发展研究》(2021030001)

Analysis of the Thematic Structure and Differences in Doctor-Patient Conversations in General Practice Clinics

  • Received:2024-11-07 Revised:2024-12-17 Accepted:2024-12-25
分享到

摘要: 背景 医患关系是医疗领域关注的焦点。全科门诊是提供连续性、综合性医疗服务的重要场所,全科医生的沟通能力对改善医患关系尤为重要,然而目前分析我国全科门诊医患沟通现状的相关研究却较少。 目的 了解全科门诊医患会话的特征和现状,以期为提高全科医生沟通能力、优化医患沟通策略、构建和谐医患关系提供实证支持。 方法 采用便利抽样法,选取1家三甲医院和3家社区卫生服务中心(站)的8名全科医生,运用自然观察法,收集其于2024年5月至8月的100份医患会话语料,使用医患互动分析系统对医患会话进行分类编码和量化分析,描述全科门诊医患会话主题结构,并分析话语差异。 结果 全科门诊的医生语言主导比例为0.92,以患者为中心的对话比例为1.27,社会心理-生物医学对话比例为0.10。医生话语主题频数最多的前三位依次是生物医学信息给予、积极对话和生物医学信息索取,而患者话语主题频数最多的前三位依次是生物医学信息给予、积极对话和社交性语言。医生在生物医学信息索取(P=0.001)和社会心理信息索取(P=0.003)上多于患者,而在生物医学信息给予(P<0.05)和社会心理信息给予(P<0.001)上少于患者。患者的社交性语言多于医生(P=0.003)。三甲医院全科医生的语言主导比例、生物医学信息索取、生物医学信息给予、生物医学建议指导、步骤性语言均高于社区全科医生(P<0.05),而社会心理-生物医学对话比例、社会心理建议指导、社交性语言均低于社区全科医生(P<0.05);三甲医院全科患者的生物医学信息索取、生物医学信息给予和积极对话均高于社区全科患者(P<0.05),而社区全科患者的社交性语言显著高于三甲医院全科患者(P<0.01)。 结论 全科门诊医患会话中患者占据话语主导地位,会话主题以生物医学为主,“以患者为中心”程度相对良好;全科医生相较于患者的索取类话语多、给予类话语少;三甲医院全科门诊相较于社区的医生语言主导比例高、生物医学类话语多、社会心理类话语少。提示全科医生应更加关注患者的情感需求、信息获取需求和疾病的社会心理因素,以促进医患沟通能力和医疗服务质量的提升。

关键词: 全科医学, 医患沟通, 医患会话, 医患互动分析系统(RIAS), 会话分析

Abstract: Background The doctor-patient relationship is the focus of attention in the medical field. General practice clinic is an important place for providing continuous and comprehensive medical services,and the communication ability of general practitioners(GPs)is particularly important for improving the doctor-patient relationship. However,there are few studies on the current situation of doctor-patient communication in general practice clinic in China. Objective To understand the characteristics and current situation of doctor-patient conversation in general practice clinic,in order to provide empirical support for improving communication skills of GPs,optimizing doctor-patient communication strategies, and building a harmonious doctor-patient relationship. Methods Convenience sampling method was used to select eight GPs from one tertiary hospital and three community health service centers(stations). Natural observation method was used to collect 100 doctor-patient conversation corpus from May to August 2024. The Roter Interaction Analysis System(RIAS)was used to classify,code and quantify the doctor-patient conversation,describe the topic structure of the conversation,and analyze the discourse differences. Results The proportion of doctor-led language dialogue was 0.92,the proportion of patient-centered dialogue was 1.27,and the proportion of psycho-biomedical dialogue was 0.10 in the general practice clinic. The three most frequent topics of physician discourse were biomedical information giving,active dialogue and biomedical information seeking,while the three most frequent topics of patient discourse were biomedical information giving,active dialogue and social language. GPs were more likely to ask for biomedical information(P=0.001)and psycho-social information (P=0.003)than patients,but less likely to give biomedical information(P<0.05)and psycho-social information(P<0.001)than patients. Patients had more social language than doctors(P=0.003). The proportion of language dominance, biomedical information seeking,biomedical information giving,biomedical advice and guidance,and step language of GPs in tertiary hospitals were higher than those in community GPs(P<0.05),while the proportion of psycho-biomedical dialogue,psycho-social advice and guidance,and social language of GPs in tertiary hospitals were lower than those in community GPs(P<0.05). The frequency of biomedical information seeking,biomedical information giving and positive dialogue of GP-patient in the tertiary hospitals were higher than those in the community GP-patient(P<0.05),while the social language of GP-patient in the community was significantly higher than that in the tertiary hospitals(P<0.01). Conclusions The patient occupies a dominant position in the discourse of the doctor-patient conversation in the general practice clinic. The theme of the doctor-patient conversation is mainly biomedical,and the degree of "patient-centered" is relatively good. Compared with patients,general practitioners had more "seeking discourses" and less "giving discourses". Compared with the GPs in the community,the GPs in the tertiary hospitals have a higher proportion of language dominance, more biomedical discourse,and less psycho-social discourse. GPs should pay more attention to patients' emotional needs,information acquisition needs and psycho-social factors of the disease,so as to improve doctor-patient communication skills and medical service quality.

Key words: General Practice, Doctor-Patient Communication, Doctor-Patient Conversation, Roter Interaction Analysis System (RIAS), Conversation Analysis