The Development of Evaluation Tools for Shared Decision Making at Home and Abroad：a Systematic Review

doi:10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2020.00.283

Abstract

Abstract: Background　Shared decision making（SDM） is a decision-making process based on the best clinical evidence and combined with patients' preferences and values. The development and application of SDM evaluation tools is of great significance to promote the practice of SDM clinically. The SDM evaluation tools have been developed maturely abroad，while related research at home is still in its infancy. Objective　To review and update systematically relevant SDM evaluation tools at home and abroad based on the existing systematic reviews，in order to provide a reference for the practice and development of SDM evaluation tools under different clinical conditions in China. Methods　In January 2019，a systematic search was conducted to retrieve the relevant literature of SDM evaluation tools in PubMed database from September of 2017 to December of 2018，and CNKI database，CQVIP database and Wanfang data database before January of 2019. The basic characteristics and psychometric characteristics of SDM evaluation tools related to reliability and validity were extracted. Results　Twelve articles conforming to the standard were retrieved including 15 evaluation tools. There were total 66 SDM evaluation tools combined with 50 evaluation tools which had been extracted from the previous systematic reviews and one tool which was found on the website of Observer OPTION Instrument. According to the application object，66 evaluation tools were divided into the tools of patient's perspective（46），doctor's perspective（4），observer's perspective（13） and multiple perspectives（3）. Among them, the contentdimension of SDM assessment tool from patient's perspective includes before, during and after patients' participation in decision-making, SDM assessment tool from doctor's perspective includes doctor's evaluation of patient's participation in decision-making and doctor's satisfaction in medical decision-making, SDM assessment tool from observer's perspective is a third-party evaluation of doctor's decision-making and patient's participation in decision-making, multi-perspective SDM assessment tool is to evaluate the degree of patients' participation in decision-making from the at least two perspectives of doctors, patients or observers. Conclusion　As the increasing attention of patient's participation in clinical decision-making，the researches of the introduction or construction of SDM evaluation tools in China are now on the rise. The construction and localization of SDM evaluation tools based on multiple perspectives needs further attention.

Key words: Shared decision making, Assessment tool, Patients' participation, Evidence-based medicine

摘要： 背景　医患共享决策（SDM）是基于最佳临床证据，结合患者的个人偏好、价值观联合进行决策的过程。SDM评估工具的开发和应用对促进临床SDM的实践具有重要意义，目前SDM评估工具在国外已有成熟发展，国内相关研究尚处于起步阶段。目的　在已有系统综述基础上，对国内外有关SDM评估工具进行系统梳理及更新，为我国有关人员在不同临床条件下选用及开发SDM评估工具提供参考。方法　于2019年1月系统检查PubMed（2017年9月—2018年12月）及中国知网、万方数据知识服务平台、维普网（建库至2019年1月）中与SDM评估工具相关的文献，获取与SDM评估工具的基本特征及信效度相关心理测量特性等信息。结果　检索到符合标准文献12篇，包括15个评估工具，结合之前SDM相关评估工具的系统综述总结的50个工具和1个观察患者参与医疗决策量表（OPTION）工具网站发现的工具，共66个SDM评估工具，根据工具应用对象不同，可分为患者视角（46个）、医生视角（4个）、观察者视角（13个）及多视角（3个）的评估工具。其中患者视角的SDM评估工具的内容维度包括患者参与决策前、患者参与决策过程、患者参与决策后，医生视角的SDM评估工具包括医生评价患者参与决策和医生在医疗决策中的满意度，观察者视角的SDM评估工具是第三方对医生决策和患者参与决策的评价，多视角评估工具是从医生、患者或观察者中至少两方的视角对同一个决策过程的患者参与决策程度进行评价。结论　随着患者参与临床决策不断受到关注和重视，我国学者引进或构建SDM评估工具的研究呈上升趋势，立足于多个视角的SDM评估工具构建及汉化需进一步受到重视。

关键词: 共享决策, 评估工具, 患者参与, 循证医学

BAI Xuefei,CAO Yu,ZHAO Yali. The Development of Evaluation Tools for Shared Decision Making at Home and Abroad：a Systematic Review　[J]. Chinese General Practice, 2021, 24(1): 109-117. DOI: 10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2020.00.283.
白雪霏,曹雨,赵亚利. 国内外医患共享决策评估工具的系统综述[J]. 中国全科医学, 2021, 24(1): 109-117. DOI: 10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2020.00.283.

References

［1］赵羚谷，王涛，王颖，等．国内外医患共同决策研究及应用进展之比较［J］．医学与哲学，2018，39（19）：6-9，57．
［2］THOMPSON-LEDUC P，CLAYMAN M L，TURCOTTE S，et al．Shared decision-making behaviours in health professionals：a systematic review of studies based on the theory of planned behaviour［J］．Health Expect，2015，18（5）：754-774．
［3］SHAY L A，LAFATA J E．Where is the evidence? A systematic review of shared decision making and patient outcomes［J］．Med Decis Making，2015，35（1）：114-131．
［4］MURRAY M A，MILLER T，FISET V，et al．Decision support：helping patients and families to find a balance at the end of life［J］．Int J Palliat Nurs，2004，10（6）：270-277．
［5］STACEY D，MURRAY M A，LEGARE F，et al．Decision coaching to support shared decision making：a framework，evidence，and implications for nursing practice，education，and policy［J］．Worldviews Evid Based Nurs，2008，5（1）：25-35．DOI：10.1111/j.1741-6787.2007.00108.x．
［6］ELWYN G，TSULUKIDZE M，EDWARDS A，et al．Using a 'talk' model of shared decision making to propose an observation-based measure：Observer OPTION 5 Item［J］．Patient Educ Couns，2013，93（2）：265-271．
［7］郑红颖，胡嘉乐，董柏君，等．医患共享决策评估工具的研究进展［J］．中华护理杂志，2018，53（5）：622-625．
［8］BOUNIOLS N，LECLERE B，MORET L．Evaluating the quality of shared decision making during the patient-carer encounter：a systematic review of tools［J］．BMC Res Notes，2016，9：382．
［9］SCHOLL I，KOELEWIJN-VAN L M，SEPUCHA K，et al．Measurement of shared decision making：a review of instruments［J］．Z Evid Fortbild Qual Gesundhwes，2011，105（4）：313-324．DOI：10.1016/j.zefq.2011.04.012．
［10］曾洁，金蕾，孙垚，等.医患共同决策过程评估工具的研究进展［J］.医学与哲学，2018，39（10）：10-13．
［11］ELWYN G，EDWARDS A，MOWLE S，et al．Measuring the involvement of patients in shared decision-making：a systematic review of instruments［J］．Patient Educ Couns，2001，43（1）：5-22．DOI：10.1016/s0738-3991(00)00149-x.
［12］DY S M．Instruments for evaluating shared medical decision making：a structured literature review［J］．Med Care Res Rev，2007，64（6）：623-649．DOI：10.1177/1077558707305941．
［13］BARR P J，ELWYN G．Measurement challenges in shared decision making：putting the 'patient' in patient-reported measures［J］．Health Expectations，2016，19（5）：993-1001．
［14］GARTNER F R，BOMHOF-ROORDINK H，SMITH I P，et al．The quality of instruments to assess the process of shared decision making：a systematic review［J］．PLoS One，2018，13（2）：e191747．DOI：10.1371/journal.pone.0191747．
［15］DEGNER L F，SLOAN J A，VENKATESH P．The control preferences scale［J］．Can J Nurs Res，1997，29（3）：21-43．
［16］NOLAN M T，HUGHES M，NARENDRA D P，et al．When patients lack capacity：the roles that patients with terminal diagnoses would choose for their physicians and loved ones in making medical decisions［J］．J Pain Symptom Manage，2005，30（4）：342-353．DOI：10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2005.04.010．
［17］徐小琳．患者对医疗决策参与的满意度量表的编制及信效度考评［D］．长沙：中南大学，2010．
［18］彭星宇．乳腺癌患者治疗护理决策参与的现状及影响因素的研究［D］．武汉：华中科技大学，2016．
［19］ENDE J，KAZIS L，ASH A，et al．Measuring patients' desire for autonomy：decision making and information-seeking preferences among medical patients［J］．J Gen Intern Med，1989，4（1）：23-30．DOI：10.1007/bf02596485．
［20］SMITH D，GARKO M，BENNETT K，et al．Patient preferences for delegation and participation：cross national support for mutuality［J］．Australian Journal of Communication，1994，21（2）：86-108．
［21］BENNETT K，SMITH D H，IRWIN H．Preferences for participation in medical decisions in China［J］．Health Communication，1999，11（3）：261-284．
［22］KIM M S，SMITH D H，YUEGUO G．Medical decision making and Chinese patients' self-construals［J］．Health Communication，1999，11（3）：249-260．
［23］KRANTZ D S，BAUM A，WIDEMAN M．Assessment of preferences for self-treatment and information in health care［J］．J Pers Soc Psychol，1980，39（5）：977-990．
［24］BRADLEY J G，ZIA M J，HAMILTON N．Patient preferences for control in medical decision making：a scenario-based approach［J］．Fam Med，1996，28（7）：496-501．DOI：10.1016/j.pec.2011.02.004．
［25］SMOLINER A，HANTIKAINEN V，MAYER H，et al．Development and test-theoretical analysis of an instrument for data collection on patients' preferences and experiences concerning participation in nursing care decisions in acute hospitals［J］．Pflege，2009，22（6）：401-409．
［26］BEISECKER A E，BEISECKER T D．Patient information-seeking behaviors when communicating with doctors［J］．Med Care，1990，28（1）：19-28．
［27］徐小琳，毛捷，王继龙，等．患者参与医疗决策期望量表的编制策略及条目筛选［J］．中国当代医药，2012，19（18）：162-164．DOI：CNKI:SUN:ZGUD.0.2012-18-095.
［28］BUNN H，O'CONNOR A．Validation of client decision-making instruments in the context of psychiatry［J］．Can J Nurs Res，1996，28（3）：13-27．DOI：10.1016/0022-3999(61)90046-0.
［29］CHEN N H，LIN Y P，LIANG S Y，et al．Conflict when making decisions about dialysis modality［J］．J Clin Nurs，2018，27（2）：138-146．DOI：10.1111/jocn.13890．
［30］刘琪．中国情境下病人参与能力的构成及现状研究［D］．长沙：中南大学，2012．
［31］Preparation for Decision Making Scale［EB/OL］．（2017-09-21）［2019-04-16］．http://decisionaid.ohri.ca/eval.html#PrepDM．
［32］BENNETT C，GRAHAM I D，KRISTJANSSON E，et al．Validation of a preparation for decision making scale［J］．Patient Educ Couns，2010，78（1）：130-133．
［33］李玉．早期原发性肝癌患者治疗决策辅助方案的构建与应用研究［D］．上海：中国人民解放军海军军医大学，2017．
［34］ARORA N K，AYANIAN J Z，GUADAGNOLI E．Examining the relationship of patients' attitudes and beliefs with their self-reported level of participation in medical decision-making［J］．Med Care，2005，43（9）：865-872．
［35］MARTIN L R，DIMATTEO M R，LEPPER H S．Facilitation of patient involvement in care：development and validation of a scale［J］．Behav Med，2001，27（3）：111-120．
［36］吴清．住院患者参与健康照护行为的影响因素及作用机制研究［D］．上海：第二军医大学，2016．
［37］SIMON D，SCHORR G，WIRTZ M，et al．Development and first validation of the shared decision-making questionnaire （SDM-Q）［J］．Patient Educ Couns，2006，63（3）：319-327．DOI：10.22074/ijfs.2019.5700．
［38］KRISTON L，SCHOLL I，HOLZEL L，et al．The 9-item shared decision making questionnaire（SDM-Q-9）．Development and psychometric properties in a primary care sample［J］．Patient Educ Couns，2010，80（1）：94-99．DOI：10.1016/j.pec.2009.09.034．
［39］明坚，魏艳，何露洋，等．患者参与决策与医学新技术使用行为的关联分析［J］．中国医院管理，2018，38（3）：19-22．

［40］LERMAN C E，BRODY D S，CAPUTO G C，et al．Patients' perceived involvement in care scale：relationship to attitudes about illness and medical care［J］．J Gen Intern Med，1990，5（1）：29-33．DOI：10.1007/bf02602306．

［41］SMITH M Y，WINKEL G，EGERT J，et al．Patient-physician communication in the context of persistent pain： validation of a modified version of the patients' perceived involvement in care scale[J]．Journal of Pain & Symptom Management，2006，32（1）：71-81．DOI：10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2006.01.007．

［42］黄韫慧．医生促进病人参与的现状及影响因素研究[D]．中南大学管理科学工程，2012．

［43］SAINIO C，LAURI S．Cancer patients' decision-making regarding treatment and nursing care[J]．J Adv Nurs，2003，41（3）：236-260．DOI：10.1046/j.1365-2648.2003.02525.x．

［44］马丽莉．癌症病人参与治疗护理决策现状及影响因素的研究[D]．中国协和医科大学，2004：1-59．

［45］缪爱云．原发性肝癌患者参与治疗方式决策现状及影响因素的研究[D]．第二军医大学护理学，2015．

［46］ELWYN G，BARR P J，GRANDE S W，et al．Developing CollaboRATE：a fast and frugal patient-reported measure of shared decision making in clinical encounters[J]．Patient Educ Couns，2013，93（1）：102-107．DOI：10.1016/j.pec.2013.05.009．

［47］MAKOUL G，CLAYMAN M L．An integrative model of shared decision making in medical encounters[J]．Patient Education and Counseling，2006，60（3）：301-312．DOI：10.1016/j.pec.2005.06.010．

［48］CHARLES C，GAFNI A，WHELAN T．Shared decision-making in the medical encounter：what does it mean?（or it takes at least two to tango）[J]．Soc Sci Med，1997，44（5）：681-692．DOI：10.1016/s0277-9536(96)00221-3．

［49］O'CONNOR A M．Validation of a decisional conflict scale[J]．Med Decis Making，1995，15（1）：25-30．DOI：10.1177/0272989X9501500105．

［50］O'CONNOR A M，TUGWELL P，WELLS G A，et al．Randomized trial of a portable，self-administered decision aid for postmenopausal women considering long-term preventive hormone therapy[J]．Med Decis Making，1998，18（3）：295-303．DOI：10．1177/0272989X9801800307．

［51］LEGARE F，KEARING S，CLAY K，et al． Are you SURE?：Assessing patient decisional conflict with a 4-item screening test[J]．Can Fam Physician，2010，56（8）：e308-e314[2019-11-18]．https://www．ncbi．nlm．nih．gov/pmc/articles/PMC2920798/．

［52］BREHAUT J C，O'CONNOR A M， WOOD T J，et al．Validation of a decision regret scale[J]．Med Decis Making，2003，23（4）：281-292．DOI：10.1177/0272989X03256005．

［53］陈芳，程晓姣．中文版决策后悔量表应用于面部美容受术者的信效度评价[J]．护理学报，2018，25（7）：42-44．DOI：10.16460/j.issn1008-9969.2018.07.042.http://www.cnki.com.cn/Article/CJFDTotal-NFHL201807015.htm．

［54］SHIOZAKI M，HIRAI K，DOHKE R，et al．Measuring the regret of bereaved family members regarding the decision to admit cancer patients to palliative care units[J]．Psychooncology，2008，17（9）：926-931．DOI：10.1002/pon.1312．

［55］SAINFORT F，BOOSKE B C．Measuring post-decision satisfaction[J]．Med Decis Making，2000，20（1）：51-61．DOI：10.1177/0272989X0002000107．

［56］HOLMES-ROVNER M，KROLL J，SCHMITT N，et al．Patient satisfaction with health care decisions： the satisfaction with decision scale[J]．Med Decis Making，1996，16（1）：58-64．DOI：10.1177/0272989X9601600114．

［57］STALMEIER P F，ROOSMALEN M S，VERHOEF L C，et al．The decision evaluation scales[J]．Patient Educ Couns，2005，57（3）：286-293．DOI：10.1016/j.pec.2004.07.010．

［58］EDWARDS A，ELWYN G，HOOD K，et al．The development of COMRADE--a patient-based outcome measure to evaluate the effectiveness of risk communication and treatment decision making in consultations[J]．Patient Educ Couns，2003，50（3）：311-322．DOI：10.1016/s0738-3991(03)00055-7．

［59］VEDAM S，STOLL K，MARTIN K，et al．The mother's autonomy in decision making（MADM） scale：patient-led development and psychometric testing of a new instrument to evaluate experience of maternity care[J]．PLoS One，2017，12（2）：e171804．DOI：10.1371/journal.pone.0171804．

［60］SCHOLL I，KRISTON L，DIRMAIER J，et al．Development and psychometric properties of the shared decision making questionnaire--physician version（SDM-Q-Doc）[J]．Patient Educ Couns，2012，88（2）：284-290．DOI：10.1016/j.pec.2012.03.005．

［61］DOLAN J G．A method for evaluating health care providers' decision making：the provider decision process assessment instrument[J]．Med Decis Making，1999，19（1）：38-41．DOI：10.1177/0272989X9901900105．

［62］ELWYN G，EDWARDS A，WENSING M，et al．Shared decision making：developing the OPTION scale for measuring patient involvement[J]．Qual Saf Health Care，2003，12（2）：93-99．DOI：10.1136/qhc.12.2.93．

［63］ELWYN G，HUTCHINGS H，EDWARDS A，et al．The OPTION scale：measuring the extent that clinicians involve patients in decision-making tasks[J]．Health Expect，2005，8（1）：34-42．DOI：10.1111/j.1369-7625.2004.00311.x．

［64］HUANG R，SONG X，WU J，et al．Assessing the feasibility and quality of shared decision making in China: evaluating a clinical encounter intervention for Chinese patients[J]．Patient Prefer Adherence，2016，31（z1）：2341-2336．DOI：10.2147/PPA.S115115．

［65］KELLER H，HIRSCH O，MULLER-ENGELMANN M，et al．Trying to optimise the German version of the OPTION scale regarding the dyadic aspect of shared decision making[J]．Methods Inf Med，2013，52（6）：514-521．DOI：10.3414/ME13-01-0011．

［66］ELWYN G，TSULUKIDZE M，EDWARDS A，et al．Using a 'talk' model of shared decision making to propose an observation-based measure：Observer OPTION 5 Item[J]．Patient Educ Couns，2013，93（2）：265-271．DOI：10.1016/j.pec.2013.08.005．

［67］SHIELDS C G，FRANKS P，FISCELLA K，et al．Rochester Participatory Decision-Making Scale （RPAD）： reliability and validity[J]．Ann Fam Med，2005，3（5）：436-442．DOI：10.1370/afm.305．

［68］SINGH S，BUTOW P，CHARLES M，et al．Shared decision making in oncology：assessing oncologist behaviour in consultations in which adjuvant therapy is considered after primary surgical treatment[J]．Health Expect，2010，13（3）：244-257．DOI：10.1111/j.1369-7625.2009.00587.x．

［69］GUIMOND P，BUNN H，O'CONNOR A M，et al．Validation of a tool to assess health practitioners' decision support and communication skills[J]．Patient Educ Couns，2003，50（3）：235-245．DOI：10.1016/s0738-3991(03)00043-0．

［70］STACEY D，TALJAARD M，DRAKE E R，et al．Audit and feedback using the brief decision support analysis tool （dsat-10） to evaluate nurse-standardized patient encounters[J]．Patient Educ Couns，2008，73（3）：519-525．DOI：10.1016/j.pec.2008.07.016．

［71］BROWN R F，BUTOW P N，JURASKOVA I，et al．Sharing decisions in breast cancer care： Development of the Decision Analysis System for Oncology（DAS-O） to identify shared decision making during treatment consultations[J]．Health Expect，2011，14（1）：29-37．DOI：10.1111/j.1369-7625.2010.00613.x．

［72］BRADDOCK C R，EDWARDS K A，HASENBERG N M，et al．Informed decision making in outpatient practice： time to get back to basics[J]．JAMA，1999，282（24）：2313-2320．DOI：10.1001/jama.282.24.2313．

［73］SALYERS M P，MATTHIAS M S，FUKUI S，et al．A coding system to measure elements of shared decision making during psychiatric visits[J]．Psychiatr Serv，2012，63（8）：779-784．DOI：10.1176/appi.ps.201100496．

［74］KEARNEY J A，BYRNE M W．Planning with parents for seriously ill children：preliminary results on the development of the parental engagement scale[J]．Palliat Support Care，2011，9（4）：367-376．DOI：10.1017/S1478951511000381．

［75］MELBOURNE E，SINCLAIR K，DURAND M A，et al．Developing a dyadic OPTION scale to measure perceptions of shared decision making[J]．Patient Educ Couns，2010，78（2）：177-183．DOI：10.1016/j.pec.2009.07.009．

［76］KASPER J，HOFFMANN F，HEESEN C，et al．MAPPIN'SDM--the multifocal approach to sharing in shared decision making[J]．PLoS One，2012，7（4）：e34849．DOI：10.1371/journal.pone.0034849．

［77］GEIGER F，KASPER J．Of blind men and elephants： suggesting SDM-MASS as a compound measure for shared decision making integrating patient，physician and observer views[J]．Z Evid Fortbild Qual Gesundhwes，2012，106（4）：284-289．DOI：10.1016/j.zefq.2012.03.020．

［78］黎贵．癌症患者临床决策中对医生、自己及家属意见倾向性的研究[D]．清华大学医学部；北京协和医学院；中国医学科学院，2009．DOI：10.7666/d.Y1495531．

［79］LAM W W，KWOK M，LIAO Q，et al．Psychometric assessment of the Chinese version of the decisional conflict scale in Chinese women making decision for breast cancer surgery[J]．Health Expect，2015，18（2）：210-220．DOI：10.1111/hex.12021．

［80］廖宗峰，金迪，梅翠红，等．患者决策冲突的研究进展[J]．护理学杂志，2018，33（12）：106-109．DOI：10.12102/j.issn.2095-8668.2018.05.005．　LIAO Z F，JIN D，MEI C H，et al．Research status and progress of patient decision conflict[J]． Journal of Nursing Science，2018，33（12）：106-109．DOI：10.12102/j.issn.2095-8668.2018.05.005．

［81］方婷，庄一渝，张秀伟．ICU患者及家属决策参与临床应用研究进展[J]．护理学杂志，2016，31（6）：109-112．DOI：10.3870/j.issn.1001-4152.2016.06.109．　FANG T，ZHUANG Y Y，ZHANG X W．Research progress of decision making of ICU patients and their family members[J]．Journal of Nursing Science，2016，31（6）：109-112．DOI：10.3870/j.issn.1001-4152.2016.06.109．

［82］FERRON P A，LABRECQUE M，ROUSSEAU M，et al．Validation of SURE， a four-item clinical checklist for detecting decisional conflict in patients[J]．Med Decis Making，2014，34（1）：54-62．DOI：10.1177/0272989X13491463．

［83］STACEY D，TALJAARD M，DRAKE E R，et al．Audit and feedback using the brief Decision Support Analysis Tool （DSAT-10） to evaluate nurse-standardized patient encounters[J]．Patient Educ Couns，2008，73（3）：519-525．DOI：10.1016/j.pec.2008.07.016．

[1]	HE Jingyi, WANG Fang, SHUI Xiaoling, LI Ling, LIANG Qian. Efficacy of Non-pharmacological Interventions to Improve Perimenopausal Insomnia Symptoms: a Network Meta-analysis [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(31): 3963-3974.
[2]	WANG Jiaxin, ZHAO Yali. Domestic and International Assessment Tools for Medical Teamwork: a Systematic Review [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(31): 3951-3962.
[3]	WEI Mengyu, WANG Jiajia, ZHANG Yingying, LI Chunyang, LI Jiansheng. Research Status of Patient-reported Outcome Assessment Tools for Obstructive Sleep Apnea [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(30): 3725-3733.
[4]	SU Guobin, LING Xitao, DUAN Ruolan, ZHANG La, XU Yuan, PENG Yu, HOU Haijing, LIU Xusheng, LU Fuhua. Selection of Therapeutic Drugs for COVID-19 Infection in Adults with Chronic Kidney Disease Based on Medical Evidence [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(26): 3220-3229.
[5]	WANG Xinyuan, WANG Xiaolei, LIU Yanli, AN Ran, LUO Jiao, LIU Xiaofei, LI Yangyang, HU Chongdie, HOU Fuwen. Advances in Evaluation Tools for Resistiveness to Care in Patients with Dementia [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(22): 2816-2822.
[6]	ZHA Qianqian, XU Lianying, CHEN Juan, HUANG Wen, ZHANG Xinqiong. Summary of Best Evidence for Prevention of Recurrence of Late-life Depression [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(19): 2332-2338.
[7]	LIU Jingtao, SU He, QIN Xiaojin, LAN Yunxia, ZHANG Jinzhi. Guidelines on Cardiac Rehabilitation in Patients with Coronary Heart Disease: a Systematic Review [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(19): 2323-2331.
[8]	YE Zhikang, YANG Hui. The Development, Problems and Application of Clinical Practice Guidelines: How Clinicians Can Read the Essence of Clinical Guidelines from the Surface to the Inside [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(13): 1559-1567.
[9]	LIU Xiao, ZHANG Jinying, PENG Yan, WANG Li, CHEN Xiaomei, LIU Jia, DENG Menghui, YANG Yanni. Summary of the Best Evidence for Dietary Nutrients Management to Promote Brain Health in Community-dwelling Residents [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(13): 1568-1576.
[10]	LUO Yachan, KONG Lingna, LYU Qiong, YAO Haiyan. Prevalence and Associated Factors of Potentially Inappropriate Medication in Community-dwelling Older Adults in China: a Meta-analysis [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(13): 1605-1612.
[11]	WANG Xixi, SHEN Rui, WANG Junjie, XU Niying. Best Evidence Summary of Exercise Interventions for Osteoporosis in Postmenopausal Women [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(09): 1151-1158.
[12]	HUA Hongxia, LIANG Hui, XU Qin, ZHU Hanfei, YANG Ningli. Reliability and Validity of the Chinese Version of Repetitive Eating Questionnaire for Patients Undergoing Bariatric Surgery [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(07): 810-815.
[13]	WANG Tong, QUAN Haishan, TIAN Bowen, LI Ying, CUI Qianqian, LIU Yao, ZHU Huahua. Fatigue in Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: a Scoping Review [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(07): 893-902.
[14]	YANG Hui, XU Yanli, YE Zhikang. Development, Application and Effectiveness of Clinical Guidelines in General Practice [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(01): 1-10.
[15]	MA Haiqi, ZHAI Huimin, BU Mengru. Recent Advances in Assessment Tools for HIV/AIDS-related Psychological Distress [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2022, 25(35): 4473-4478.