Bibliometric analysis of the research hotspots of hierarchical diagnosis and treatment in China

doi:10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2020.00.202

Abstract

Abstract: Background　Hierarchical diagnosis and treatment is an important measure to realize the social division of labor in medical institutions and to solve the problem of "difficulties to access medical services".Comprehending its research hotspots and trends is helpful for the implementation of hierarchical diagnosis and treatment.Objective　To identify current research hotspots and trends of hierarchical diagnosis and treatment in China，to provide a reference for sustainable research of this field.Methods　1 162 articles about hierarchical diagnosis and treatment were searched from CNKI database.SATI 3.2 was used to input the publication year，and source journal of the articles，and generated keywords co-occurrence matrix.Netdraw，a program within the Ucinet 6.0 suite，and SPSS 19.0 were applied to draw the co-occurrence network diagram and tree diagram showing hierarchical clustering using the keywords co-occurrence matrix.Results　The research on hierarchical diagnosis and treatment in China started in 1993，and the amount of studies showed an increasing trend year by year.Its development can be roughly divided into foundation phase（1993—2008），slow growth phase（2009—2014） and rapid growth phase（2015—）. The top three journals owning greatest amount of studies are Chinese General Practice（277 articles，23.84%），Chinese Hospital Management（120 articles，10.33%） and Chinese Health Economics（99 articles，8.52%）.The top three high-frequency key words were hierarchical diagnosis and treatment（424 times），two-way referral（249 times），community health services （164 times）.The two-way referral was at the core of the co-network diagram，and is the most important link for hierarchical diagnosis and treatment.Healthcare-seeking behaviors，counterpart support，integrated medical and nursing care，medical service prices，high quality care and informatization were on the edge of the map，which are the research trends.According to the tree diagram，the high-frequency key words were summarized into five thematic clusters：influencing factors of hierarchical diagnosis and treatment within the regional medical consortium，perception of and satisfaction with first contact services in primary care，integration and optimal allocation of medical resources，health management services delivered mainly by general practitioners，and referrals，healthcare-seeking behaviors and medical costs in patients with chronic diseases.Conclusion　Available studies about hierarchical diagnosis and treatment in China are summarized as follows on the basis of analyzing of the research hotspots and trends：promoting the implementation of hierarchical diagnosis and treatment via carrying out first contact services in primary care，and using the platform of regional medical consortium，referral services for hypertension，diabetes and other chronic diseases，and health management services provided mainly by general practitioners.

Key words: Hierarchical diagnosis and treatment, Referral and consultation, Bibliometrics, Word frequency analysis, Cluster analysis, Research hotspots

摘要： 背景　分级诊疗是实现医疗机构社会分工、解决人民群众“看病难”问题的重要举措。了解其研究热点及趋势，有助于分级诊疗的实施。目的　分析我国分级诊疗领域研究热点及趋势，为其可持续性研究提供参考。方法　在中国知网（CNKI）中检索分级诊疗相关文献1 162篇，导入文献题录信息统计分析工具SATI 3.2，统计文献发表年份、来源期刊，并生成关键词共词矩阵，将共词矩阵分别导入Ucinet 6.0的Netdraw程序和SPSS 19.0软件中绘制共现网络图谱和聚类树图。结果　我国分级诊疗相关研究始于1993年，文献量逐年增多，大致可分为奠基期（1993—2008年）、缓慢增长期（2009—2014年）、快速增长期（2015年以后）；载文量排在前3位的期刊为《中国全科医学》（277篇，23.84%）、《中国医院管理》（120篇，10.33%）、《中国卫生经济》（99篇，8.52%）；频次排在前3位的关键词为分级诊疗（424次）、双向转诊（249次）、社区卫生服务（164次）。双向转诊处于共现网络图谱核心位置，是分级诊疗最重要节点；就医行为、对口支援、医养结合、医疗服务价格、优质护理、信息化等处于图谱边缘，是分级诊疗领域的研究趋势。通过聚类树图将高频关键词归纳为5个主题类团：以医疗联合体为载体的分级诊疗影响因素研究，基层首诊认知及满意度研究，医疗资源整合及优化配置研究，以全科医生为主的健康管理服务研究，慢性病患者的转诊、就医行为及医疗费用研究。结论　综合研究热点及趋势，我国分级诊疗相关研究主要为：以基层首诊促进分级诊疗实施，以高血压、糖尿病等慢性病患者的转诊，以全科医生为主的健康管理服务，以医疗联合体为载体促进分级诊疗的研究。

关键词: 分级诊疗, 转诊和会诊, 文献计量学, 词频分析, 聚类分析, 研究热点

YUAN Chengju,YU Changyin,ZHANG Nian, et al. Bibliometric analysis of the research hotspots of hierarchical diagnosis and treatment in China[J]. Chinese General Practice, 2020, 23(19): 2390-2395. DOI: 10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2020.00.202.
袁成菊,余昌胤,张年等. 我国分级诊疗研究热点的文献计量学分析[J]. 中国全科医学, 2020, 23(19): 2390-2395. DOI: 10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2020.00.202.

References

［1］杨超，郑雪倩，高树宽．立法推进分级诊疗制度建设的思考［J］．中国医院管理，2018，38（2）：21-23. YANG C，ZHENG X Q，GAO S K．Reflections on the legislation to promote the construction of classified management system［J］．Chinese Hospital Management，2018，38（2）：21-23. ［2］魏瑞斌．基于关键词的情报学研究主题分析［J］．情报科学，2006，24（9）：1400-1404，1434．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-7634.2006.09.027. WEI R B．Analysis of the research subject of information science based on the keyword［J］．Information Science，2006，24（9）：1400-1404，1434．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-7634.2006.09.027. ［3］钟海艳．SWOT 分析法在图书馆学中的应用研究［J］．河南图书馆学刊，2013，33（8）：105-106，118．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1003-1588.2013.08.043. ［4］孙葵，尹文强，黄冬梅，等．分级诊疗制度下乡镇卫生院医疗服务承载力分析［J］．中国卫生经济，2018，37（4）：57-60．DOI：10.7664/CHE20180417. SUN K，YIN W Q，HUANG D M，et al．Analysis on medical service carrying capacity of township health centers under hierarchical diagnosis system［J］．Chinese Health Economics，2018，37（4）：57-60．DOI：10.7664/CHE20180417. ［5］黎迎，刘忠卫，焦明丽，等．基于社会分工理论的分级诊疗服务体系研究［J］．中国医院管理，2018，38（2）：26-27，30. LI Y，LIU Z W，JIAO M L，et al．Research on improvement of classification and diagnosis service system based on social division theory［J］．Chinese Hospital Management，2018，38（2）：26-27，30. ［6］吕本艳，李黎，王亚辉，等．基层医务人员对基层首诊制的认可度及影响因素研究［J］．中国卫生统计，2018，35（6）：892-894. ［7］王宁宁，徐淑一．我国中老年人门诊医疗服务利用的影响因素及城乡差异分析［J］．医学与社会，2017，30（5）：48-51，70．DOI：10.13723/j.yxysh.2017.05.016. ［8］张年，余昌胤，黄辉华，等．基于扎根理论的贵州省双向转诊影响因素质性研究［J］．中国医院管理，2018，38（11）：14-16. ZHANG N，YU C Y，HUANG H H，et al．Qualitative analysis of the influencing factor characterictics of two-way referral in Guizhou Province based on grounded theory［J］．Chinese Hospital Management，2018，38（11）：14-16. ［9］汤榕彬．分级诊疗政策背景下厦门城市居民基层首诊意愿及其就医行为研究［D］．泉州：华侨大学，2018. ［10］卢若艳，李跃平，郑振佺，等．慢性病分级诊疗实施现状及障碍分析［J］．卫生经济研究，2017，34（1）：41-43．DOI：10.14055/j.cnki.33-1056/f.20170105.009. ［11］马新雅，关旭静，唐雪峰，等．分级诊疗制度下基层医疗卫生机构2型糖尿病患者健康管理绩效评价指标体系的建立［J］．现代预防医学，2019，46（3）：467-471. MA X Y，GUAN X J，TANG X F，et al．Performance evaluation index system of health management for type 2 diabetes patients in primary medical and health institutions based on the hierarchical medical system［J］．Modern Preventive Medicine，2019，46（3）：467-471. ［12］戴慧敏，刘伟，吴培红，等．2型糖尿病“全科-专科”分级诊疗协作管理模式及开展现状研究［J］．中国全科医学，2018，21（10）：1188-1192．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.10.009. DAI H M，LIU W，WU P H，et al．Theory and implementation of general-specialty hierarchical management mode for type 2 diabetes［J］．Chinese General Practice，2018，21（10）：1188-1192．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.10.009. ［13］耿桂灵，宋彦玲，肖玉华．医养结合理念下老年慢性病患者延续护理模式构建分析［J］．护理管理杂志，2015，15（6）：381-382，416. GENG G L，SONG Y L，XIAO Y H．The model of continuous nursing in older people with chronic diseases：a strategy of combining health and pension［J］．Journal of Nursing Administration，2015，15（6）：381-382，416. ［14］王丽萍，徐爱军．高血压患者的治疗路径及分级诊疗开展现状研究［J］．中国全科医学，2018，21（10）：1183-1187，1192．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.10.008. WANG L P，XU A J.Development of hierarchical treatment for hypertension in China：a study based on the analysis of hypertension treatment pathways［J］．Chinese General Practice，2018，21（10）：1183-1187，1192．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.10.008. ［15］巩昕，石建伟，肖月，等．我国高血压双向转诊标准的研究现状［J］．中国全科医学，2018，21（34）：4194-4200. GONG X，SHI J W，XIAO Y，et al．Hypertension bidirectional referral criteria in China：a literature analysis［J］．Chinese General Practice，2018，21（34）：4194-4200. ［16］何媛媛，李军山，操文婷．分级诊疗模式中全科医生制度建设研究［J］．卫生经济研究，2018，35（3）：48-50，54．DOI：10.14055/j.cnki.33-1056/f.20180302.008. HE Y Y，LI J S，CAO W T．Study on the construction of general practitioners system in the graded system of diagnosis and treatment［J］．Health Economics Research，2018，35（3）：48-50，54．DOI：10.14055/j.cnki.33-1056/f.20180302.008. ［17］肖蕾，张太慧，张雅莉，等．分级诊疗视角下家庭医生签约服务 “签而不约”的原因及对策研究［J］．中国全科医学，2018，21（25）：3063-3068．DOI：10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.25.007. XIAO L，ZHANG T H，ZHANG Y L，et al．Reasons and countermeasures of residents signing the contract with the family doctor but not making appointments during the implementation of hierarchical medical system［J］．Chinese General Practice，2018，21（25）：3063-3068．DOI：10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.25.007. ［18］高凤娟，杜学锋，史宇晖，等．全科医生签约服务在北京德胜社区原发性高血压病患者分级诊疗中的效果评价［J］．中国全科医学，2018，21（9）：1070-1074．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.00.056. GAO F J，DU X F，SHI Y H，et al．Evaluation of the effect of contracted service mode of the general practitioner on the hierarchical diagnosis and treatment of patients with primary hypertension in the desheng community of Beijing City［J］．Chinese General Practice，2018，21（9）：1070-1074．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.00.056. ［19］刘利群．推进家庭医生签约服务加强分级诊疗制度建设［J］．中国全科医学，2018，21（1）：1-4．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.01.001. LIU L Q．Promoting contracted services of family doctors to strengthen the construction of hierarchical medical system［J］．Chinese General Practice，2018，21（1）：1-4．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.01.001. ［20］胡玲，吴燕萍．浙江省关于推进责任医生签约服务的实践探讨［J］．中国全科医学，2017，20（31）：3835-3840．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2017.31.001. HU L，WU Y P．Practice of contracting service with doctors in primary care institutions project in Zhejiang Province［J］．Chinese General Practice，2017，20（31）：3835-3840．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1007-9572.2017.31.001. ［21］王荣华，李云涛，赵玲，等．基层全科医生在医联体内的角色定位研究［J］．中国全科医学，2019，22（1）：5-9．DOI：10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2019.01.002. WANG R H，LI Y T，ZHAO L，et al．Roles of general practitioners working in primary healthcare settings joining in a regional medical consortium［J］．Chinese General Practice，2019，22（1）：5-9．DOI：10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2019.01.002. ［22］李珺，俞卫．公立医院改革中的医生薪酬问题研究——基于上海市公立医院的经验数据［J］．价格理论与实践，2019，39（2）：149-152. LI J，YU W．Research on doctors' salary in the reform of public hospitals——based on empirical data of public hospitals in Shanghai［J］．Price：Theory & Practice，2019，39（2）：149-152. ［23］张年，余昌胤，黄辉华，等．贵州省医疗联合体建设和发展的问题及对策——基于扎根理论的质性研究［J］．中国卫生政策研究，2019，12（4）：44-49．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1674-2982.2019.04.007. ZHANG N，YU C Y，HUANG H H，et al．Analysis of existing challenges and countermeasures in the construction and development of regional medical union in Guizhou Province：a qualitative research based on grounded theory［J］．Chinese Journal of Health Policy，2019，12（4）：44-49．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1674-2982.2019.04.007. ［24］张兴祥，陈申荣.我国分级诊疗改革政策实施效果的量化评估:以试点城市厦门为例［J］．福建论坛：人文社会科学版，2019（2）：192-204. ［25］程洁，徐向天，王哲，等．医联体“专全结合”慢性病管理模式及其对开展分级诊疗的作用研究［J］．中国全科医学，2018，21（34）：4178-4182．DOI：10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.34.004. CHENG J，XU X T，WANG Z，et al．Development of the chronic disease management team consisting mainly of specialists and general practitioners from the institutions of a medical consortium and its role in the implementation of the hierarchical medical system［J］．Chinese General Practice，2018，21（34）：4178-4182．DOI：10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2018.34.004. ［26］李文敏，李文志，曾祥英．影响我国分级诊疗制度推进的关键问题研究［J］．中国卫生政策研究，2018，11（10）：12-19．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1674-2982.2018.10.002. LI W M，LI W Z，ZENG X Y．Research on the key issues affecting the promotion of hierarchical medical system in China［J］．Chinese Journal of Health Policy，2018，11（10）：12-19．DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1674-2982.2018.10.002.

[1]	FENG Xiaoyu, LI Wanling, LYU Siman, NI Cuiping, WANG Haocheng, LIU Yu. International Research Status and Hot Spot Analysis of InterRAI HC Based on Bibliometrics [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(34): 4351-4358.
[2]	XU Jian, DAI Fangfang, PAN Wenlei, HUANG Qian, LU Ping, WANG Jianfeng, JIA Huan, YANG Yuqi, HUANG Jiaoling. Visual Analysis of Hotspots and Cutting-edge Trends of Community TCM Service Research in China in the Context of Healthy China [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(34): 4343-4350.
[3]	WANG Min, GUO Wenjun, CHEN Yongzhen, FENG Xinyu, TANG Zhongquan, ZHAO Xiaomin, OU Ting, DAI Xinyu, LI Yuntao. Bibliometrics and Visualization Analysis of Medically Unexplained Physical Symptoms Based on Web of Science Database [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(31): 3930-3938.
[4]	ZHENG Xiao, TIAN Feng, CHEN Yiming, XUE Benli, SHI Lei, ZHANG Chichen. Research Hotspots and Evolutionary Trends on Multimorbidity in China from 2002 to 2022 [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(21): 2567-2573.
[5]	FENG Jia, WANG Jie, YU Dan, LIU Yongheng, ZHAO Weidong, TIAN Hongyuan. Analysis of Research Hotspots of Multiple Chronic Conditions in the Elderly in 2010-2021 [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(21): 2574-2580.
[6]	XIA Yuxian, FU Lijuan, LUO Wenyi, SHEN Xiaoyi, NI Ping. Family Management Styles and Associated Factors for Children after Palliative Surgery for Complex Congenital Heart Disease [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(16): 1995-2003.
[7]	ZHANG Nian, YU Changyin, ZHU Jiming, LI Fei, CHEN Lingli, PU Haifeng. Research Hotspots and Trends on the Training of Targeted Admission Medical Students in China [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(04): 486-493.
[8]	WANG Jun, ZHANG Dong, FENG Zhenzhen, ZHANG Shujuan, ZHAO Guixiang, ZHANG Hailong, LI Jiansheng. Literature-based Research on Common Syndromes of Cough Variant Asthma [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2023, 26(03): 321-328.
[9]	CAO Xingyang, WANG Yang, XU Zhijie, XU Yanli. Primary Care and General Practice Research Paper Productivity Report in China in 2021 [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2022, 25(34): 4232-4240,4258.
[10]	JIN Hua, FU Qiangqiang, YU Dehua. Research Hotspots and Trends of General Practice and Community Health in China: Based on the Data of Chinese Journals in General Practice from 2001 to 2020 [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2022, 25(34): 4241-4251.
[11]	FU Qiangqiang, JIN Hua, YU Dehua. Development Status and Strategy of Research Capability of General Practice and Community Health in China: Based on the Data of Chinese Journals in General Practice from 2001 to 2020 [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2022, 25(34): 4252-4258.
[12]	Kai YU, Jiachun WANG, Zhaoyuan ZHOU, Xinyue CHEN, Shuang WANG. Chronic Disease Management in Primary Care in China: Recent Advances and Hotspot Analysis Using VOSviewer [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2022, 25(28): 3493-3501.
[13]	Qi ZHANG, Baozhen LI, Xuemei ZHENG, Baohua PING, Xiaoyan WANG, Qian LI. Research Hotspots of Multidrug-resistant Organisms in China from 2000 to 2020: a Visualization Analysis [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2022, 25(24): 2960-2964.
[14]	Yizhen NIE, Zhaoqi YAN, Wei YAN, Hongmei FU, Xingjuan ZHAO, Hui YIN, Qunhong WU. A Clinical Study of Structural Properties of Osteosarcopenic Obesity Syndrome Using Multivariate Statistical Methods [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2022, 25(22): 2733-2739.
[15]	Bixia XU, Xiaodan LIN, Weiguang YAO. Children's Intention to Seek Healthcare in Primary Healthcare Settings and Associated Determinants: an Analysis Using the Anderson's Behavioral Model of Health Services Use [J]. Chinese General Practice, 2022, 25(22): 2766-2772.